A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza: Authentic New York Flavors in Lancaster

This is my go to spot for pie whenever I’m craving a GOOD pie. AMAZING service and dedication from the staff! It was a VERY HAPPY VALENTINE’s FOR me when they surprised us by making the pie a heart . Thank you to the staff for always making their business a place where I feel welcomed.

Brooklyn is my family’s preferred pizza place. New York style thin crust and always delicious. Never had a bad meal and on Valentine’s Day they gave us very sweet surprise. This team cares about the food, but also its customers. Stop in say hi and grab a slice, you won’t be disappointed.

Might be the best pizza around. It’s hard to tell how good a place is based on reviews. All these shops have over 4 stars and they’re almost all mediocre. Brooklyn stands out. Maybe the best white pizza I’ve ever had. Everyone skimps on the ricotta nowadays for some reason, but not these guys. Excellent.

The best gluten free pizza in Lancaster! I have tried at least 5 different gluten free pizzas around town and this one blows the others out of the water. Actually tastes like an authentic Italian pizza only the crust is a little on the crunchy side which is pretty standard for gluten free. However it doesn’t taste like cardboard like all the others- it has a really nice flavor. My husband (not gluten free) recommends the Brooklyn Full House pizza.

Very friendly, sweet little pizza shop. My family and I agree the drunken grandma pizza (Sicilian style) was the best we ever had ! Will be back!!!!!

Pizza was good!!! Two dollars for a topping on a medium is kind of pricey, but that’s how they get you. But the pizza is good

First time visit to Brooklyn Pizza, and likely not my last! Excellent food, friendly service, inviting atmosphere. Comments from my party included, "Drool-worthy food" and "I don't typically like warm wraps, but their's is so good!" plus my 2-year polished off an entire (giant) slice. The staff initiated several offers of kid-friendly accommodations including warm pizza instead of piping hot, option to cut the giant slice in half or into small pieces, kid-sized cups, and offered to clear the trash/trays from our table. The entire restaurant interior was clean and organized. The fairly small dining area led to a cozy atmosphere, but was initially a bit crowded before clearing out after lunchtime. Along the same theme, the parking lot is a bit small but likely appropriately sized for the space available. Extensive menu with various offerings beyond their many pizza options. Small kids menu with 4 non-pizza options. We enjoyed large portions of pizza, calzones, wraps, fries, onion rings, and mozzarella sticks; take out boxes were a necessity and the restaurant provided a variety of appropriately-shaped/sized boxes to bring our leftovers home for later. I would highly recommend getting food at Brooklyn Pizza, and I hope to be back sometime soon!

Great pizza thats always fresh. I love the way they bake the pepperoni pizza. So good. The people working there are always friendly too.